e.l.f. No Budge Retractable Eyeliner, Creamy, Ultra-Pigmented & Waterproof, Creates Bold & Defined Lines, Vegan & Cruelty-Free, Black

This is a great eyeliner, I love the brown, it’s great for lining the waterline or creating a soft wing. It’s easy to blend and build. And the price is great!

Pro: I like both the brown and charcoal color, softness and it glides well with the sharp point along the eye line on both upper and lower lashes. I was careful to let it set for 30 seconds so it wouldn't smudge, and it lasted all day for me. I didn't remove it with anything, just washed my face with tepid water and in the morning nothing was on my silk pillowcase so that was fine with me. I can't comment on how waterproof it is, but it has great smudge resistance once set.Con: I've only used it once, so I have no idea how long it will last yet. It doesn't have a built-in sharpener and crayon is quite thin so I'm not giving it 5 stars until I've had it long enough. If Amazon allows an update, I'll do a followup review. Updated: 9-13-25 - I continue to purchase these when I need them, but I only use it 2 or 3 times a week. It has lasted me well enough, that I am giving it an extra star because it is soft and doesn't drag on my eyelids. I'm elderly now, so that's an important consideration as my skin ages! It's not 'waterproof' in my opinion, but that's an aspect that I prefer. It doesn't smear once set and comes off easily in the shower.

I'd like to give this eyeliner 5 stars, as it is a quality product, going on easily and it stays put. However, I found that I must be allergic to an ingredient in the product. I use other make up of this brand, with no reaction.

I literally just put this in the cart to get to the same day shipping minimum for something urgently needed, but I am glad I picked it. I wore this for the first time to an amusement park, so I can say it is rollercoaster proof.A lot of times, I end up with this extra arc of black where eyeliner meets the deeper part of my eyelid, and this was no exception. At this point, I think it is unavoidable. For five bucks, I don't expect much. I would say it was a thinner and fainter streak than some $12 eyeliner I have used, which absolutely counts for something, but it did transfer a bit despite giving every effort for it to be totally dry/done before relaxing.Otherwise, it held up really well, stayed put. Easy to apply, I actually usually prefer liquid liner but this was a lot easier/forgiving.

Awesome price. Really black. Stays put. Great liner.

It works really nice but it doesn’t get on my waterline as I wanted to. That’s what I bought it for from my upper water line and it doesn’t really stick so I’m just wondering if it’s because it’s new I have to keep using it so it could stick there or it’s just not made for it but on my skin, it does not move so it’s good

I love this eyeliner. The color is exactly as shown, it applies smoothly, and it lasts all day without smudging. I’ve repurchased it multiple times and will definitely keep buying it. A safe and reliable choice!

Love it, it’s super creamy and so black. It’s long and easy to hold. It doesn’t irritate my eyes either I used it in my waterline and to do a wing and it was great, my eyes didn’t even water. Would prob last a good month or so depending on how often you’d use it.